Redefining the Gridiron: A Deeper Look into NFL’s Top Quarterback Rankings for 2023

The new NFL season of 2023-24 is on the horizon, and it’s time to sharpen our focus on the most pivotal role in the sport – the quarterback. Recently, The Athletic published its yearly quarterback tiers and rankings, formulated through the lens of 50 notable NFL coaches and executives. These rankings triggered an intriguing response from Skip Bayless, the noted sports commentator from FOX Sports, prompting a comprehensive evaluation of these rankings.

The Premier League of Quarterbacks

1. Joe Burrow, Cincinnati Bengals

According to Bayless, Burrow and Patrick Mahomes are two players who deservedly occupy the top slots. Though Bayless leans slightly towards Burrow, he believes that the spoils of victory in the previous season entitle Mahomes to be on top, placing Burrow as a close second.

2. Josh Allen, Buffalo Bills

Bayless concurs with an NFL coordinator’s assessment of Allen, expressing doubts about his consistency as a drop-back passer – an essential trait for a top-tier quarterback. While he acknowledges Allen’s talent, Bayless isn’t entirely sold on his game-changing potential.

Redefining the Gridiron: A Deeper Look into NFL's Top Quarterback Rankings for 2023 NFL

The Hype, the Talent, and the Controversies

3. Aaron Rodgers, New York Jets

Labeling Rodgers as the most “overhyped, overrated” player in the NFL, Bayless questions the projection of him being a top-tier player. He contrasts Rodgers’ move to the Jets with Tom Brady’s shift to Tampa Bay, emphasizing Brady’s superior leadership and clutch-playing skills.

4. Justin Herbert, Los Angeles Chargers

Bayless offers a critique on Herbert’s performance, stating that he doesn’t see the same promise that others do. While acknowledging Herbert’s talent, Bayless disagrees with a defensive coordinator’s comparison of Herbert to Deshaun Watson. He further points out Herbert’s shortcomings in crucial games, casting doubts on his game-winning capabilities.

Tier Two Standouts

5. Jalen Hurts, Philadelphia Eagles; Lamar Jackson, Baltimore Ravens; Trevor Lawrence, Jacksonville Jaguars

For these three quarterbacks, Bayless is not shy about his favoritism over Dak Prescott. He affirms that he would choose Hurts, Jackson, or Lawrence over Prescott given their performances in the previous season, particularly highlighting Lawrence’s triumph over Prescott in Jacksonville.

The Prescott Predicament

6. Dak Prescott, Dallas Cowboys

Bayless presents a detailed assessment of Prescott, acknowledging his ability to produce impressive stats, but also highlighting his frequent shortcomings. He attributes some of Prescott’s success to Kellen Moore and points out that Prescott led the NFL in interceptions thrown, questioning his potential as a game-winning quarterback.

7. Kirk Cousins, Minnesota Vikings

Despite his criticism of Prescott, Bayless admits that he’d still choose Prescott over Cousins, subtly underlining his doubts about Cousins’ capabilities.

The Final Say

Bayless’ appraisal of the quarterback rankings delivers a bold and candid insight into the dynamics of NFL’s 2023 quarterback line-up. While he appreciates certain players’ talents, he also exposes the overhyped personas and controversial performances. His predictions and assessments lay a critical groundwork for the upcoming season, setting the stage for a heated and exciting NFL showdown.

As we gear up for the new NFL season, these rankings offer a roadmap of what to expect, inviting fans and critics alike to form their own opinions. One thing is for sure: the coming NFL season promises to be thrilling, filled with suspense, challenges, and hard-fought victories.


Maybe You Like Them Too

Leave a Reply

68 + = 73